The Cosmic Collections competition has been running for a few weeks now, and while we’ve been sucked into a vortex of other projects, I’ve been keeping an eye out for feedback from the public.
As a result, I’ve realised that there may be some mismatch between the way mashups tend to work, and the scope we’ve suggested for entries to our competition. The types of interfaces someone might produce with the API may lend themselves more to exploring one particular idea in depth than produce something suitable for the broadest range of our audiences.
So I’m proposing to change the scope for entries to the competition, to make it more realistic and a better experience for entrants: I’d like to ask you to build a section of a site, rather than a whole site. The scope for entrants would then be: “create something that does one thing, and does it well”. Our criteria – use of collections data, creativity, accessibility, user experience and ease of deployment and maintenance – are still important but we’ll consider them alongside the type of mashup you submit.
This might mean producing a mashup for one particular way of exploring the objects, or exploring a sub-set of the objects. It’d then be up to us to combine the winning mashups into a larger site that works for our audiences.
What do you think? If there aren’t any huge objections, I’ll go ahead and update the criteria. Of course, if you’ve been working on something and feel it’s unfair to change the criteria at this stage, let me know and we’ll work something out.
As a reminder, here are the basic details for the Cosmic Collections competition:
How to take part
1. Check out the data here
2. Get some help:
Read our tips for entrants, check out these mashup resources, and get some info about our audiences. Check out the documentation and connect with other people who want to enter the competiton. You can also join the Google group or use the hashtag #coscultcom in conversations on Twitter.
3. Get inspired
Visit the exhibition and check out these videos about the exhibition
4. Get creative and get mashing!
5. Send us a link to your entry.
Email us by midnight on November 28 (GMT) – you don’t need to pre-register.
(And the title? I’m a big fan of the Unix philosophy, “do one thing and do it well”.)